TIIOCTI design your own tote bag with a full colour art print on the panel

What Should a Printed Bag Spec Say About Color Fastness?

Built from the legacy color fastness article and the tote and moving bag spec data, reorganised around a single purchase order.

by Nick Lee·7 min read·2026-08-19

Built from the legacy color fastness article and the tote and moving bag spec data, reorganised around a single purchase order.

A complaint landed on a buyer's desk in early spring: the printed shopping bags "felt cheap," and the ink came off on the customer's palm. The bag had passed every check the buyer knew to write into the order, so the problem was not the factory. It was a single row on the purchase order that said "Grade 4" and stopped there, without saying grade 4 of what, measured how, or on which substrate.

That row is where print color is actually controlled. A printed bag does not have one fastness number. It has several, each tied to a different stress: a hand dragging across the print, a window full of daylight, a washing machine cycle. The spec sheet has to name all of them, or the factory will test the easiest one and the buyer will discover the rest at the store.

The Row That Says Grade 4 and Nothing Else

On the order form, the fastness line usually reads like this: "Color fastness: grade 4." It looks decisive. It tells the factory almost nothing.

Fastness grades run from 1, severe bleeding, to 5, no visible transfer, and the pass threshold sits somewhere between those two ends. A bare "grade 4" does not say whether that is a rubbing result, a light result, or a wash result, and those three are scored on different scales. Rubbing and washing read against the gray scale, where grade 4 means slight transfer visible only on close inspection. Light fastness reads against the blue wool reference scale, which runs 1 through 8, so a grade 4 there is a different position on a different ruler.

The fix is to split the row. Write one line for rubbing, one for light, one for wash, and attach a method to each. A buyer who does that has converted a promise into a number a laboratory can reproduce.

Rubbing: The Line Buyers Read First

A metal probe presses a white fabric strap against dark cloth beside a grey test card.

Rubbing, or crocking, is the failure a customer sees first, because printed handles touch hands thousands of times across a reuse cycle. The method mounts fabric on a crockmeter, drags a standard white cotton finger cloth across the print under 9 N of force, and reads the stained cloth against the gray scale.

The spec line should read: dry crocking grade 4 minimum, wet crocking grade 3 minimum, under AATCC 8 or ISO 105-X12. Those thresholds are common across retail programs, and premium or display heavy programs sometimes raise wet rubbing to grade 3-4.

Why two numbers instead of one? Wet rubbing is the harder test. Moisture softens the binder that holds pigment to the surface, so a print that survives a dry drag can still smear when a damp hand grips the handle. Dark saturated prints on light nonwoven polypropylene are the classic risk case, and that combination is where a single dry grade hides the problem.

To verify, ask for the crocking pair as a separate report line, not folded into a general "color fastness" summary. The stained cloths should be photographed alongside the gray scale so the grade can be read, not just trusted.

Light: The Line That Only Matters in a Window

Several plain white canvas tote bags hang in a row in front of a shop window.

A bag that passes rubbing can still fade. Bags that sit in storefront windows or outdoor market stalls lose color to daylight, and light fastness is the grade that predicts it. AATCC 16 exposes samples to xenon arc light matched to daylight, and the result is read against blue wool.

For retail display programs, grade 4 on blue wool is the floor. Below that, a bag can look correct on the shelf and washed out by the third week in a window.

This line gets skipped because most buyers picture the bag in a hand, not on a display stand. The question to ask is simple: will this bag spend its life indoors under artificial light, or will it face a window or a market stall? If the answer is a window, the light line belongs on the order with its own method and its own threshold.

Rub fastness and light fastness are different failure modes. A print can transfer nothing under rubbing yet grade 2 on blue wool and fade within weeks of daylight exposure. One test does not cover the other.

Wash: The Line Reusable Programs Live On

Four grey fabric swatches lie on a white table beside two colour comparison charts.

Reusable programs live or die on laundering, and wash fastness is graded after a defined cycle rather than a single rinse. ISO 105-C06 runs a 40 degree Celsius wash for 30 minutes in a standard detergent solution, and the washed specimen is compared against a retained original.

The working spec for reusable programs is grade 4 color change and grade 4 staining after cycle 3. Both halves matter. Color change tracks the print fading on the bag; staining tracks color bleeding onto whatever else shares the load.

Prints that rely on insufficient curing ovens fail here first. Curing is the heat step that locks pigment into the fabric, and a print that looks perfect off the line can release color in the first warm wash if that step ran short. A wash test is the cheapest way to catch a curing problem before a rental fleet or a grocery chain does.

To verify, request the cycle count and the detergent used, not just the final grade. A grade 4 after one cycle and a grade 4 after three are not the same claim.

The Method Column Nobody Fills In

A blank order form on a desk under a magnifying glass, with a pen and stacked fabric swatches.

Every fastness line needs three parts: the stress, the grade, and the method. The method column is the one left blank most often, and it is the one that decides whether two laboratories will agree.

AATCC 8 and ISO 105-X12 both describe rubbing, but a report that names neither leaves the buyer unable to compare a factory's claim against a third party result. The same applies to AATCC 16 for light and ISO 105-C06 for wash. Naming the method costs one line and removes an entire argument later.

There is a second reason to fill it in. Testing only protects the buyer when the pass levels are contractual. A grade written into a purchase order is a commitment; a grade mentioned in an email is a preference. When the method and threshold sit in the contract, a failed report becomes a claim rather than a conversation.

Where the Grade Gets Tested in the Order

The spec sheet decides what gets tested, and the production schedule decides when. A first article pass does not certify month six of production. Batch to batch ink lots and curing drift move grades by a full step, so a print that scored grade 4 in the sample room can score grade 3 in a later run without anyone changing the artwork.

That is why the fastness line should carry a frequency, not just a threshold. A first article test at the start of the run, plus a retest at a defined interval or at each ink lot change, keeps the number honest. Pull, seam strength and bar tack are already tested on every batch in a well run line; fastness deserves a schedule of its own rather than a single pass at the start.

The practical check for a buyer is to look at the inspection plan and find the fastness line on it. If the only fastness result in the file is dated to the sample stage, the production bags have not been tested at all.

The Line That Moves Between Batches

A natural canvas tote bag and a black tote bag stand side by side against a plain wall.

The most overlooked row is not rubbing, light, or wash. It is the substrate line, the one that names the fabric and the print route the grade applies to.

A cotton canvas bag printed by screen print or heat transfer does not behave like a nonwoven polypropylene promotional bag under the same ink load. Nonwoven polypropylene with heavy pigment load is actually the highest risk substrate, so the grade 4 dry and grade 3 wet thresholds belong in the contract for promotional bags too, not just for totes. Canvas totes come in a natural shell or a dyed shell, and a dyed shell can change how a print reads against the gray scale.

When the substrate line is missing, a factory can test the easiest fabric in the range and report a grade that says nothing about the bag the buyer ordered. The row that controls print color is the one that ties the grade to the exact fabric, the exact print route, and the exact method. Everything above it is a number without a home.

FAQ

What grade should a printed shopping bag reach for dry and wet rubbing?

Specify dry crocking grade 4 and wet crocking grade 3 minimum under AATCC 8 or ISO 105-X12. Premium and display heavy programs often raise wet rubbing to grade 3-4.

Why did a bag pass the rub test but fade in a store window?

Rub fastness and light fastness are different failure modes. A print can transfer nothing under rubbing yet grade 2 on blue wool and fade within weeks of daylight exposure.

Do the same fastness grades apply to nonwoven promotional bags?

Yes, the same scales apply. Nonwoven polypropylene with heavy pigment load is the highest risk substrate, so keep the grade 4 dry and grade 3 wet thresholds in the contract.

How often should fastness be retested during a production run?

At minimum on the first article and again at each ink lot change or defined interval. Batch to batch ink lots and curing drift can move a grade by a full step.

Discuss your bag project
Start a quote→